Iscador and Mistletoe

When Suzanne Somers announced on Larry King Live that she was using Iscador in her breast cancer treatment, there was a surge of interest in mistletoe.

Iscador is a derivative of Viscum album, a mistletoe plant that grows in many parts of the world. Medical mistletoe is the result of many years of painstaking effort to explain the suggestion made by Rudolf Steiner (1981-1925) that mistletoe could be rendered effective in the treatment of cancer.

This is the story:

Steiner was a mystic and founder of Anthroposophy, considered by some to be an offshoot of Theosophy that came into being during the war years when communications to the German-language world were disrupted. Steiner was not, however, entirely derivative. He was, in many respects original.

The researchers who developed Iscador took their hints from the vision that Steiner had that mistletoe could be emancipated from both Cosmic and terrestrial forces. How so?

Mistletoe is a parasitic plant. It does not grow in the soil (not the species referred to by Steiner) but in the bark of trees. It grows perpendicular to the branch in which it thrusts its sucker, and it does not obey many of the laws of the plant kingdom. For instance, its berries ripen in winter, without warmth. It stores up chlorophyll and is green all year long and is indifferent to light. It is thus neither geotropic or phototropic and this is the fact that fascinated Anthroposophical researchers Kaelin and Leroi.

While Steiner felt that mistletoe could replace the scalpel, Anthroposophical doctors are quick to admit that Iscador is not there yet. They use Iscador in conjunction with conventional therapies, such as irradiation, to protect against injury. Iscador itself comes in many varieties. It is made by fermentation, not the usual powder or alcoholic extracts.

The Doctrine of Similars

Steiner's statements did not make it easy for those who wished to make practical use of his understanding. He suggested making a preparation of the winter and summer Viscum album, a parasitic plant that grows on trees and may have some behavioral characteristics similar to cancer. It took a number of Anthroposophic doctors many years to develop a treatment based on mistletoe.

Mistletoe does not grow on healthy trees. When it does grow on trees, removing the mistletoe results in the death of the tree. This is truly fascinating. The mistletoe may actually be performing a service to the tree, but what would happen to the mistletoe if the tree is healed?

Facts of the Somers' Story

Suzanne Somers was diagnosed with breast cancer in April 2001. The routine mammogram had failed to reveal a 2.4 cm tumor; the mass was found using ultrasound. Somers had a lumpectomy. The lymph nodes that were removed were clean. The surgery was followed by radiation. Experts could not agree on whether or not to recommend chemotherapy. She made the the decision not to undergo chemotherapy—and she has gone to great lengths to emphasize that this was a personal decision, not necessarily something she advocates for others.

In her announcement, Somers referred to the 1000-page book by Burton Goldberg. Here are some relevant excerpts from the material on Iscador:

Iscador is "made from fermented extracts of European mistletoe, some forms of which are combined with small amounts of metals to produce certain desired, anticancer effects."

Further down, there is a quotation from a a Dr. Richard Wagner of Stuttgatt who says, "it is immediately apparent that patients given mistletoe treatment have better survival quality (than those on chemotherapy), with the survival period presumably the same. We would therefore always prefer mistletoe treatment in this particular situation."

Somers seems to believe that Iscador is a homeopathic remedy and has published material on her choices on her web site. Her confusion may be due to the fact that the doctor providing the treatment is a well-known homeopath; however, Iscador—in the form developed in Europe—is not a homeopathic remedy.

Office of Technology Assessments

In a 1990 report, the OTA published the following:

Mistletoe has long been used in the treatment of a variety of acute and chronic conditions. It was not widely used for treating cancer, however, until the 1920s, during the early development of Anthroposophy, a modern 'spiritual science' applied to medicine and a variety of other disciplines. At present, mistletoe is given to patients either as the central component of a complex, broader treatment regimen in the practice of Anthroposophic medicine mainly in Europe or as a single agent partially or completely removed from the overall context of Anthroposophic care (e.g., in the United Kingdom and other countries). At present, mistletoe preparations are advocated mainly by Swiss and German physicians practicing Anthroposophic medicine, but are also used by other European physicians not necessarily associated with Anthroposophy. A larger group of researchers in Europe, and to a lesser extent in the United States, has focused on the study of mistletoe's biological properties in various experimental systems.

Iscador Treatment

Iscador is used extensively in a well-known clinic in Switzerland, the Lukas Clinik. Taking its cue from Steiner, the clinic offers the following comments on cancer:

Cancer can be many things - disease, destiny, opportunity, life drama or tragedy, a biographical turning point. But it is always a biological process and part of life.

It goes on to discuss the biological processes in a mixture of scientific, philosophical, and poetic speculations. According to them, cells come into being through a process of division, and they have a certain life expectancy based on the genetic potential. The death of cells, apoptosis, is assumed to be subject to the vagaries of fate and genes. Cells have a life cycle, birth to death, and before death, they pass information to the new cell, basically explaining to the new cells its functions as well as what it should look like, how it should divide, and when it will die.

There is really nothing new about this theory except the assumptions about how information is transferred. We all know that cells divide and that when they do, they may be absolutely normal or deformed. Some abnormal cells die and others replicate. Basically, cancer is a disease characterized by excessive reproduction of abnormal cells. The theories that affect why a cell mutates during the course of division are numerous: alcohol, tobacco, infection, pH imbalances, radiation, toxicity, nutrient deficiencies, message errors, and, of course, the catchall: stress. One theory is that the more deviant the cell is, the faster it reproduces; however, in the case of healthy individuals, these cells have a lower survival potential: they die and are consumed by white blood cells.

Development of Medicine from Mistletoe

With the thoroughness of German scientific inquiry, a botanist named Karl von Tubeuf began in 1907 to collect all that was known about mistletoe, this from science, mythology, and cultural traditions. He published a monograph in 1923. Both von Tubeuf and Steiner were fascinated by the anomalies of the plant.

Mistletoe has little white berries that are quite toxic to humans, but birds enjoy them. The birds either eat only the pulp and leave a sticky seed in the tree or they eat the whole berry, seed and all, and deposit the sticky payload when they eliminate the undigested seed when they pass fecal material. The seed sinks a sucker rootlet into the tree from which it derives water and nutrients. This is why it is called a parasitic or semi-parasitic plant, but the European species seldom cause the death of their hosts.

The growth process of the ball-like mistletoe plant is slow. It flowers after 5-7 years but is only harvested for use in medicines after 10-15 years. The first "Anthroposophical mistletoe medicines" were made by a Dr. Ita Wegman in 1917. Working with a pharmacist, she developed an injectible form of mistletoe. Scientific papers were presented at an Anthroposophical conference in 1920 and then in 1935, Dr. Wegman established the Society for Cancer Research in Arlesheim. Production of Iscador was first carried out by the highly respected Anthroposophical firm, Weleda AG, but it is now produced by the Hiscia Institute which belongs to the Society for Cancer Research. The name Iscador comes from the Greek for mistletoe, ixos os ixia.

 

Author's Remarks

Steiner used complex metaphysics to express his understanding, in general as well as specifically when applied to mistletoe. He felt that science and spirituality could work together to create medicines of the future. Where cancer is concerned, he felt that there are various organizing forces that result in degrees of chaos or order. His theories are basically nearly impossible to address with the tools of modern medicine. It is therefore necessary to look at results rather than mechanisms for action.

Iscador is not seen by those who use it as a cure for cancer. It is a treatment that most often is used in conjunction with other conventional treatments, especially radiation but also surgery. It is given both before and after these procedures so as to promote rapid recovery and reduce adverse reactions, such as metastasis. Different studies seem to suggest different assessments of the treatment. When used instead of chemotherapy, the quality of life is significantly better for patients being treated with Iscador than for patients undergoing chemotherapy. For those who are treating localized tumors, especially of the breast but also of the cervix, ovaries, breast, stomach, colon, and lungs, survival may be as much as 40% longer for patients using Iscador than those going a 100% conventional route. As this OTA statement suggests, no one who has studied the results refers to Iscador as a cure, merely as a treatment.

Treatment with Iscador is generally not claimed to result in dramatic destruction of tumors. Instead, it is thought to slow the growth of tumors or even stop tumor growth altogether, and then lead to gradual tumor regression. It is believed that tumor cells may undergo a transformation from malignant forms to semimalignant forms, then to chronic inflammation, and finally to normal forms.

Having devoted more than three decades to medical philosophy and alternative treatments, it is with some reticence and yet support that I wish to note that many of the serious investigations of unusual protocols have been carried out in Germany where: (1) holistic medicine is not a step child but rather an optional pursuit in normal medical schools, and (2) mysticism and medicine have found an alliance, not only in Anthroposophical medicine but Hildegard medicine and Father Kneipp's therapies. I said "reticence" not because of any personal hesitation but rather awareness that science invariably wishes to prove matters on its own terms.

Copyright by Ingrid Naiman 2003

For more information on Iscador:

The summary of what is known about medicine made from mistletoe from the National Cancer Institute is as follows: